dinsdag 8 september 2015

Belgian versus German infantry weapons


Disclaimer: It is not always possible to check copyrights on pictures. I will remove them in case of unauthorised use.
For more detailed information, much can be found here:  http://world.guns.ru/
Many orginal pictures are available here: http://18daagseveldtocht.wikispaces.com/

This time, I will write about the standard infantry weapons of Belgium and Germany in 1940. Both Belgium and Germany expanded their armed forces in 1930's. Weapon production had trouble keeping up so both sides used older weapons next to newer ones.

Belgium

Handguns

The standard Belgian handgun was the FN Browning Grand Puissance (High Power) in 9mm Parabellum (9x19). It had a magazine capacity of 13 rounds. A lot more than the 8 rounds of the Luger or the 6 rounds in the British Webley and Enfield revolvers. It was a reliable weapon. The Germans restarted production in occupied Belgium for their own use. The Browning HP was also used by the Western Allies.

This weapon was the standard armament of officers in combat units and crews who operated heavy machineguns, mortars or anti-tankguns.

Browning High Power made by FN (model 1935).

Some older FN Browning handguns were also in use like the model 1903, 1910 and 1922. Most of these used 7.65x17mm Browning ammunition. These older weapons were issued to rear-echelon units.

Submachine guns

The standard submachine gun was the Mitraillette Modèle 1934. This weapon was a licence produced version of the German MP28/II. The submachine guns were produced by the Belgian company Societe Anonyme Anciens Establissments Pieper Bayard. The smg was fed by box magazines holding 32 rounds of 9mm Parabellum. It was a very good and reliable weapon, but a bit expensive to produce. Captured weapons seemed to have been used by the Germans.

Two assistants of the commander of an infantry company were armed with a Mitraillette 34. Eight men in the regimental reconnaissance platoon were also armed with this weapon. Active and first reserve divisions had about 80 MP34's total. The Chasseurs Ardennais also received a large amount of Mitraillette 34's, about 216.

 Schmeisser MP-28/II submachine gun, with box magazine shown separately.


Rifles

The standard rifles in use in 1940 were the FN Modèle 1935 and Modèle 1936. Both were based on the Mauser design. The Modèle 1935 was produced by FN and M.A.E. (Manufature d'Armes de l'Etat). These rifles were manufactured from completely new parts. Because of the rapid expansion of the Belgian army a second weapon was produced, the Modèle 1936.



The Modèle 1936 made use of the stock of old Mauser Modèle 1889 rifles. Some parts of the old weapons were reused but they received a new barrel, sights, hand-shield, recoil spacer , barrel bands, bayonet stud, front sight with ears are those of the MOD. 35. This made them nearly identical to the Modèle 1935 but a bit cheaper to make. The Modèle 1936 was produced by M.A.E. and Pieper.



Divisions of second reserve and rear-echelon units used the original Mauser Modèle 1889. These weapons were worn out from use in the First World War. All three rifles used the standard 7,65 X 54 mm ammunition. The Belgian 7,65x54 mm ammunition was an effective round and it was used by all Belgian rifles and machineguns.

The Belgian FN Mauser designs have much in common with the standard German Mauser Karabiner 98k and other bolt-action rifles. Bolt-action rifles formed the main armament of infantrymen during WW1 and WW2. These rifles generally had a calibre between 7.5 and 7.92mm and held about five rounds. Some countries, like Italy, the Netherlands and Japan used 6.5mm ammunition.  A common complaint about these lighter 6.5mm rounds was that the bullets did not inflict enough damage to take out an enemy with one shot. These armies also used a different bigger calibre for their heavy machineguns. This complicated logistics.  

This site contains more info and pictures.
http://www.littlegun.be/arme%20belge/fusils%20reglementaires/1%201%20armes%20reglementaires%20gb.htm

Light machineguns

The standard light machinegun in Belgian service was the Fusil-mitrailleur modèle 1930, FM30. This was a Belgian version of the Browning Automatic Rifle. The Belgian design had a pistol grip and fired the standard Belgian 7.65x54mm from a 20-round magazine. The weapons had a handle on top. The FM30 Model D had a quick-change barrel. The weapon was usually  fired from its bipod. A light tripod for ground and anti-aircraft fire was also in use. This weapon equipped all infantry divisions of active and 1st reserve, as well as the cavalry and the Chasseurs Ardennais. Each Belgian infantry platoon had four LMG's.

Infanterie_FM30.jpg

The weapon weighed 9 kg, a bit more than the US BAR. It had a fire-selector with two options. The first option was a reduced rate-of-fire of 350 rounds per minute. The second option was 600 rpm.  
The option for a reduced rate-of-fire allowed the gunner to conserve ammunition when rapid fire was not required. This option was used most frequently in combat. The high ROF was recommended in crisis moments when assaulted by enemies. The F.M.30 was a reliable and accurate weapon. Its main drawback was the rather small 20 round magazine. The F.M.30 had a good front grip. This meant that the MG could be fired from the hip if necessary.

Most light machineguns in 1940 used magazines. Magazines were positioned underneath the gun, on top or from the side. Feeding the gun from below allowed for a good vision and a balanced weight but restricted the size of the magazine. Magazines on top could carry about 30 rounds and provided a balanced weigth but blocked the vision. Magazines on the side unbalanced the gun. The German MG34 was fed by a 50 round drum magazine or by belts. Belts had a much larger capacity of up to 250 rounds. However the operators needed to make sure that the belt did not get stuck. The assistant gunner was responsable for this task. The MG34 weighed 12kg, more than most other light machineguns.

Belgian infantry divisions of 2nd reserve were equipped with the older Chauchat light machinegun. This weapon had been used by the Belgians in WW1. All LMG's fired the standard 7,65 X 54 mm ammunition from a 20-round magazine. This fully enclosed magazine was a good improvement over the original open magazine. Still, these weapons were quite old and worn out.

Afbeeldingsresultaat voor Chauchat 20 round41Li_Chauchat_Mauser.jpg



Heavy machineguns

Active and 1st reserve infantry divisions used the Maxim MG08 heavy machinegun on its typical sled mount. Again, all HMG's used the standard 7,65 X 54 mm ammunition. Belgium bought several of these weapons prior to WW1 and received many ex-German wepaons. It was a heavy weapon but it could put out a lot of fire.

8Li_Maxim.JPGLeie_Maxim.jpg

The Chasseurs Ardennais and the motorised cavalry used the French Hotchkiss Modèle 1914. The Hotchkiss weighed about 25kg, a lot less than the MG08 with 65kg. This lighter weight made it well suited for the mobile Chasseurs Ardennais and cavalry.



As always the divisions of 2nd reserve had to make do with older weapons, the M1895 Colt–Browning machine gun. It had a relatively low firing rate: 400-450 rpm versus 500-600 of the MG08.

colt_machinegeweer.jpg

Light mortar

The final Belgian piece of equipment that I want to talk about is the DBT lance-grenades (light mortar). Every infantry platoon in active and first reserve divisions had three of these. German and British platoons only had one light mortar per platoon.

This light mortar fired 50mm grenades with a weight of 600 grammes and had a maximum range of 600 meter. Both HE and smoke rounds were available.



More info at:
http://www.littlegun.be/arme%20belge/fusils%20reglementaires/1%201934%20dbt%20fr.htm 

Grenades

The Belgian Army had two kinds of grenades. Offensive O.F. grenades with a smaller fragmentation effect and defensive Mills grenades with a much larger fragmentation effect. The 6 men of the F.G group carried 3 grenades each. 

Germany

Handguns

The most common German handgun was the Luger in 9mm Parabellum. The army also made use of the Walther P38. The Walther and Luger held 8 rounds in a magazine. Later in the war, Germany made made extensive use of the Belgian FN Browning High Power.

P-08 - standart sidearm of German Military during WW I and WW II.Walther P38, produced in 1944 for Hitler's army.


Submachine guns

Many photo's of German soldiers show them armed with submachine guns. In reality, the large majority of all soldiers were armed with bolt-action rifles. MP's were often given to NCO's. They had a rather short range, but the high rate of fire made them excellent at close quarters combat. The Germans started the war with the MP18 from WW1 and the improved MP28/II. These were good weapons but rather expensive to make. The MP38 and MP40 were cheaper weapons with similar performances. All these weapons fired the 9mm Parabellum. German divisions of the 1ste Welle had 312 submachineguns. Divisions of other recruitment waves had less of them. Later in the war, the Germans would often use Soviet PPSh41's on the Eastern Front or Italian Beretta's in Italy to increase their access to MP's.

MP-38 submachine gun.











German soldiers in Norway with a MP28.


Rifles

The standard German rifle during WW2 was the Mauser Kar98k. This was a shortened version of the Mauser Gewehr 98 from WW1. The Kar98k was a standard bolt-action rifle with an internal magazine of 5 rounds. The Kar98k fired the standard German 7.92x57mm Mauser ammo.

 Mauser K98k - same 1944-made specimen, right side view.
Germany also used captured Polish and Czech rifles. 

Light machineguns

The standard German LMG was the MG34. The MG34 was a belt-fed general-purpose machinegun that could serve as a LMG with a bipod or as a heavy machinegun with tripod. The weapon could be loaded with a 50 round drum magazine or with belts. This MG had a maximum rate-of-fire of 900 RPM. It had a quick-change barrel for cooling. The MG34 was a versatile weapon. It could put down a lot of fire if plenty of ammunition was available. This was often the case on the defense, when ammunition could be stored in the trenches. 

On the attack, soldiers would have to make do with what they could carry or bring forward. The standard ammunition load for a German squad was 1150 rounds. Note that the standard load for a Belgian squad was 1120 rounds. To save ammo, MG34-gunners had to shoot short aimed bursts of fire.  
MG-34 as a light machine gun, with 50 rounds belt drum-like box.

The Germans were short on MG34's in 1940. The armed forces had expandede rapidly  and the MG34 had to serve both as LMG and HMG. This meant that other weapons were also used in 1940. Many infantry divisions used the MG13. This weapon had been adopted in the early 1930's. It was air-cooled weapon that was loaded with 25 round magazines from the side.

MG 13 with box magazine, left side.

A third weapon that was used in 1940 was the MG 26(t). These were ZB 26 LMG's captured from the Czechs. This weapon was especially used by the Waffen SS divisions in 1940. It was fed by a 20 round magazine from the top.

ZB vz.26 light machine gun, leftside.



Heavy machineguns

As written above, Germany also used the MG34 as a heavy machinegun. The MG34 was a versatile weapon. German units had the option to fire the MG34 as a HMG with tripod or they could dismount their weapons and attack as regular infantry. This gave them a lot of flexibility.

In 1940, many HMG units in German infantry divisions were equipped with the old watercooled Maxim MG08 due to the short supply of new weapons. The MG08 is the same weapon as the Belgians used but it fired the German 7.92x57mm Mauser ammo.
 MG-34 as a medium gun, on tripod Maxim MG 08 medium machine gunon its peculiar



Light mortar

The standard German light mortar was the 5cm Granatwerfer 36. Every German platoon had one of these. It had a range of 520 meters. 
1666 - Salzburg - Festung Hohensalzburg - Leichter Granatwerfer M35.JPG

Flamethrower

German assault pioneer units had a special but devastating weapon: the Flammenwerfer 35. It had a rang of about 25 meters and weighed 35.8 kg. They used it to attack bunkers and fortifications. 


Grenades


The Germans used several grenades. The Model 24 grenade Stielhandgranate is the most famous. The Model 39 Eihandgranate is another popular grenade. 

Conclusion

There is not a lot of difference between German and Belgian infantry weapons. The Belgian army used several weapons of German design like the Mauser rifles, Mitraillette 34 and Maxim MG08. On the other hand, Germay would use several captured weapons after the armistice, especially the FN Browning High Power.

The MG34 is the most noteworthy German weapon. Its high ROF made it a very potent weapon. The first burst of fire on inattentive enemies could do a lot of damage before they could take cover.But as I said, other LMG's were used in 1940 to fill in shortages. The German infantry squad did not carry more ammo on the attack than the Belgians. It was mostly later in the war when the Germans were on the defence that the true firepower of the MG34 and MG42 mattered. The Germans, short on manpower, began to rely more and more on the firepower of the MG34 and MG42. The tasks of the German riflemen in the infantry squad became protecting the MG and carrying ammo. However on the attack, the poor bloody infantry still had to assault and clear positions.

The best German infantry divisions had a significant amount of submachineguns. But most soldiers were still armed with the simple but reliable Mauser K98k. Belgian divisions had less SMG's, but still had a decent amount of them. British and French divisions actually didn't have any submachineguns in use yet in 1940. The French MAS-38 was only taken in production around the time of the German invasion. The British did not have much interest until after the fall of France. They used American Thompsons at first and produced the Sten later during WW2.
.


vrijdag 17 juli 2015

British and French infantry divisions

To complement my previous post, I have collected information about standard British and French divisions.

From http://www.britishmilitaryhistory.co.uk/documents.php?aid=166&nid=23&start=5 
and http://www.niehorster.org/017_britain/40_org/inf%20div/_inf-div.html


Quantity and weapon
British infantry division
Manpower
+- 13863 all ranks
Sub-machineguns
0 (?)
Scoped rifles
unknown
Flamethrowers
0 (?)
Anti-tankrifles
361
Light machineguns
644
Heavy machineguns
144
Light mortars 2-inch
108
Medium mortars 3-inch
18
Towed anti-tank guns
48 + 27 French 25mm guns
Light tanks Vickers VIB
28*
Scout Cars
50*
Carriers
90
25-pdr field guns
72
Anti-aircraft machineguns
Some of the LMG's are AA weapons.
* Not all divisions had a divisional cavalry regiment with light tanks and Scout Cars. Only five had one: the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 51st division. Three other regiments were part of the 1st Light Armoured Reconnaissance Brigade.
(?) I am not 100% certain about these figures.

A British division at full strenght had a lot of LMG's and artillery. The presence of carriers and light tanks is remarkable. They provided the division with a useful reconnaisance element. The British lack some regimental weapons like medium mortars. The Vickers HMG's were officially part of a separate MG battalion and not part of the combat brigades. The 2pdr anti-tankguns were part of the artillery regiment. A lot of the supporting weapons were situated at divisional level unlike German, French or Belgian divisions. 


Quantity and weapon
French infantry division
Manpower
+- 17500 all ranks
Sub-machineguns
0 (?)
Scoped rifles
unknown
Flamethrowers
0 (?)
Anti-tankrifles
0
Light machineguns
346
Heavy machineguns
168
Light mortars 60mm
27
Medium mortars 81mm
24
Towed anti-tank guns 25mm and 47mm
51-54 X 25mm + 8 X 47mm = 59-62
Field guns 75mm
48
Howitsers 105mm
12
Howitsers 155mm
12
Anti-aircraft guns 25mm
6

A full strenght French divsion was relatively well equipped. The most remarkable element is the small calibre of their most common anti-tank gun. The Hotchkiss modèle 1934 was underpowered compared to many 37-47mm guns. The additional 47mm SA 37 was one of the best anti-tank guns available at the time.

woensdag 15 juli 2015

Small and ill-equipped?

Common history books about May 1940 often focus on the German, British and French army and neglect the Belgian (and Dutch) army. They often summarise it as follows: "The Belgian army was small, ill-equipped and surrendered quickly." After that, they continue writing about the three major powers. I have written in my previous post that Belgium raised a fighting force of 610.000 men. Not exactly a small force and even larger than the British Expeditionary Force with 450.000 men. The Belgian Navy and Army Airforce were poorly equipped. That is true. The ground force, however was reasonably well equipped. It is important to keep the trade-off between quantity and quality in mind. The BEF was well equipped and mobile, but with 10 combat ready infantry divisions rather small compared to the forces of Germany and France. The forces of France and Belgium on the other hand were very large compared to the size of their population and resources. Officers, NCO's, weapons, communication and transport equipment... All of it was spread amongst more units instead of concentrated in a smaller professional force. Germany, with a larger population, had a slightly better balance of quantity versus quality and could make use of captured Czech and Polish weapons to equip some units.

Population numbers
Belgian population in 1940: 8,3 million
Dutch population in 1940: 8.8 million
French population in 1940: 40 million
United Kingdom population in 1940: 48 million
German population in 1940: 70 million (+ the resources of Czechoslovakia and Poland)


Combat divisions available for the German front in 1940
Belgium: 22                                     divisions/million population: 2.65  
Netherlands: 10                                divisions/million population: 1.14
France: 94                                        divisions/million population: 2.35
UK: 10                                             divisions/million population: 0.21
Allies: 136                                                  divisions/million population: 1.29
Germany: 135                                  divisions/million population: 1.93

This simple calculation only includes combat divisions available for the front in North-West Europe. It doesn't include navies, Air Forces or units in Norway, colonies or other places. The British Royal Navy, for instance fought the Kriegsmarine in Norwegian waters. The Norwegian Campaign from 9 April - 10 June 1940 occurred at the same time as the Battle of Belgium 10 - 28 May 1940.

Both France and Great Britain sent ground units to Norway. These troops landed in several places. They did not operate at divisional stength. These units had the size of a regiment or battalion. One could say that the Allies had the equivalent of one British and one French division in Norway.
Germany sent two mountain divisions and five infantry divisions to Norway. The Norwegian army counted six divisional military districts. In reality each district could only muster a unit of brigade size. Norway had a population of 2,9 million in 1940. I would say that Norway had the equivalent of three normal divisions. (1.03 division equivalents/million of population)

These figures are important to interpret the strenght and armament of the Belgian divisions. We can see that Belgium had a very large force compared to its size. If Belgium had 1.93 divisions per million of population like Germany, then it would have a force of 16 divisions. This means that the six poorly equipped divisions of 2nd reserve did not have a German equivalent. 

Now let us look at the firepower of the Belgian active and 1st reserve divisions:

Quantity and weapon
Belgian active and 1st reserve division
Manpower
+- 17650 all ranks
Sub-machineguns
80
Scoped rifles
120
Flamethrowers
0
Anti-tankrifles
0
Light machineguns
344
Heavy machineguns
148
Light mortars DBT (50mm)
246
Medium mortars M76 (76mm)
24
Towed anti-tank guns
48
T13 tankhunters
12
Field guns C75TR or C75GP (75mm)
36
Howitsers Ob105GP (105mm)
12
Anti-aircraft machineguns MG08/15
64

Belgian 2nd reserve:

Quantity and weapon
Belgian 2nd reserve division
Manpower
+- 12205 all ranks
Sub-machineguns
0
Scoped rifles
42
Flamethrowers
0
Anti-tankrifles
0
Light machineguns
356
Heavy machineguns
116
Light mortars DBT (50mm)
0     (They had 324 VB riflegrenade launchers.)
Medium mortars M76 (76mm)
0
Towed anti-tank guns
0
T13 tankhunters
0
Field guns C75TR or C75GP (75mm)
24
Howitsers Ob105GP (105mm)
0
Anti-aircraft machineguns MG08/15
24

A German infantry division from the 1st Welle:

Quantity and weapon
German 1st Welle
Manpower
+- 17734 all ranks
Sub-machineguns
312
Scoped rifles
unknown
Flamethrowers
9
Anti-tank rifles
90
Light machineguns
435*
Heavy machineguns
110
Light mortars (50mm)
84
Medium mortars (81mm)
54
Light infantry gun leIG18
20
Heavy infantry gun sIG33
6
Towed anti-tank guns
75
Tankhunters
0
Light armoured cars
3
Medium Howitsers (105mm)
36
Heavy Howitsers (155mm)
12
Anti-aircraft guns (20mm)
12*
* Some of the LMG’s were used as anti-aircraft weapons.

A German infantry division from the 2nd Welle:

Quantity and weapon
German 2nd Welle
Manpower
+- 15273 all ranks
Sub-machineguns
unknown
Scoped rifles
unknown
Flamethrowers
9
Anti-tank rifles
90
Light machineguns
345*
Heavy machineguns
114
Light mortars (50mm)
unknown
Medium mortars (81mm)
unknown
Light infantry gun leIG18
26
Heavy infantry gun sIG33
0
Towed anti-tank guns
75
Tankhunters
0
Armoured cars
3
Medium Howitsers (105mm)
36
Heavy Howitsers (155mm)
12
Anti-aircraft guns (20mm)
0*
* Some of the LMG’s were used as anti-aircraft weapons.

The divisions of the other waves (Wellen) had a bit less firepower than the 1ste Welle and counted less men, around 15000 all ranks.

The Germans have a bit more LMG's, sub-machineguns and flamethrowers. They also have more medium mortars and infantry guns. Their artillery had larger calibres. This gave them a bit more offensive power. 

The Belgian divisions had more light mortars and heavy machineguns. Their artillery was largely made up of fast-firing field guns. This gave them an adequate defensive power. It is also apparent that a Belgian divisions had more armoured vehicles than a German division. This is expected due to differences in doctrine.

The Belgian divisions on 2nd reserve were very poorly equipped. But as I said earlier this is a consequence of the very large size of the Belgian Army. 

I think that we can conclude that a standard German division did not have a decisive advantage in firepower despite some differences. Many German infantry divisions had participated in the Polish campaign and were trained in the Stosstruppen tactics. They benefitted more from their experience and training, than from superior weapons.